Tracking code caldwell guardian

Saturday, October 10, 2009

City Sends Guardian Intimidating Letter Re: THE TRUTH IS..

THE GUARDIAN received a rather intimidating letter via CERTIFIED MAIL RETURN RECEIPT REQUESTED (postage was $5.54) from the City Clerk of Caldwell today (Saturday 10-10).

In what can only be described as an attempt to limit free speech, the Caldwell city clerk has sent the CALDWELL GUARDIAN a lengthy letter apparently alleging some sort of illegal activity for sharing information about the upcoming city election. It is no secret the GUARDIAN and others are not happy with the current crop of incumbents up for reelection. While we don't advocate FOR any particular candidate, we don't advocate AGAINST any specific candidate either--we are against ALL the incumbents up for reelection. Here is the document at issue:


Current incumbents up for reelection in Caldwell have worked harder at getting along with one another than performing the due diligence for their elected responsibilities

Current incumbents have presided over MILLIONS of our dollars spent or lost on projects that offer no productive value to taxpayers:

At least three downtown studies costing nearly $400,000.00
Paid Oppenheimer Group $50,000.00
Homeland Security cell towers that don’t work $750,000.00
Construction plans for TVCC at Sky Ranch Business Park $150,000.00
Over spent on downtown property purchases to the tune of millions
Doubled county assessments for Caldwell commercial and retail property owners
$300,000.00 to the Mercado building for Oregon based TVCC
Failed to keep the Canyon County Fair in Caldwell
Caldwell has the second highest PROPERTY TAX LEVY rate in Idaho

Incumbents have actually contributed to the further demise of downtown Caldwell. We now have a net loss to downtown economic base.

One third of all property taxes collected, $6 million, is getting spent by elected officials via the Urban Renewal Agency with no voter oversight. (UR board is ELJAY WAITE, GARRET NANCOLAS, ROB HOPPER, STEVE RULE, LEONA FOUTS AND TWO ELECTED SCHOOL BOARD MEMBERS)

We are being governed and our money spent by “MAYORAL PROCLAMATION” instead of a defined plan and voter oversight for millions of our property tax dollars.


The City Clerk states "Earlier this week, it came to my attention that a particular flyer has been widely circulated with respect to the upcoming election. I contacted two individuals who were known to be reproducing and/or distributing the flyer. Since that time I have been advised that the flyer had been created by you. In reliance on that information , I am writing you to inform you of the same information provided to them." The City Clerk goes on to cite all manner of Idaho Codes.

Perhaps citing a bunch of Idaho codes can be construed by some as "educational and informative." We think it improper for the clerk to be involved in judging what is and what is NOT free speech. The city attorney or county prosecutor would be the ones to decide if laws are being broken and they would have to convince a jury that exercising rights guaranteed by the Constitution of the United States of America is somehow contrary to the sensibilities of the Caldwell City Clerk.


  1. I grew up in Canyon County and through volunteer work I have been in and out of your jail for years. I do not believe in giving the inmates all the comforts of home but do believe in sanitary conditons. I think it became obvious that when the powers that be decided they wanted a new jail that they went about making it look and smell as bad as they could to make a point. The lack of mainitenance has been one of the biggest issues for this jail. You need to send a message to these out of control elected officials and remind them who they work for. Vote down the jail bond. We have the same problems in Owyhee County. They have forgot who their employer is.

  2. You've obviously hit a nerve !! I'd consider it a badge of honor!

    Brian Vermillion.

  3. I would like to know how much the Caldwell "City Attorney" makes per year from my tax dollars. I just paid tripled+ bills for my properties on Pioneer Irrigation all because these 2 entities would rather fight than have some sane, mature dialogue and get their disputes settled. But no, let's just keep on battling and pad the pockets of these attorney's. Incredible egos with no thought to the people they are supposedly representing.

  4. Pretty hard to judge what the truth is here. Nothing in the section you reprinted from the City Clerks' letter seems to be telling you you can't distribute the flyer. Did the letter tell you to cease distributing the flyers? What Idaho Code provisions did it cite? How is it intimidating?

    Sorry but until I see more of the letter than what you've posted so far I have a hard time seeing this letter as "intimidating" or as seeking to limit free speech.

  5. I would like a copy of the letter from the city.


A public discourse on the issues of the day makes the world a better place.

We welcome comments but they will be moderated and edited if too long or do not have anything to do with the post.
Agree or disagree just do it without profanity or it won't get posted. Try to keep your comments to no more than 300 words. Too long and I will try to edit it down or simply delete the comment. The whole idea is to get people to read your comment. Don't use 10 words when one will do the job.

It's OK to have a difference of opinion but keep it civil. I have used the "delete" feature on myself at times.

The ANONYMOUS feature for comments seems to be the most user friendly. People have commented they have difficulty with the other methods of posting comments.