Tracking code caldwell guardian

Friday, November 20, 2009

Jail Woes Put Jail Bed Costs on Sale! Hurry Before Sale Ends

What a deal! It must be Christmas and Black Friday for Jail Beds. Canyon County just got to rent jail beds for $40/day. It now costs Canyon County $84/day to run our jail per comments made by Commissioner Kathy Alder to a public service group last week.

Jail bond costs were going to be $10,000/day ($3.6 Million a year) just to pay back the interest and principle on the loan. THE GUARDIAN would submit to the Commishes they need to consider renting all the jail beds they can for $40/day. This is a 52% mark down from what it now costs us per bed to run our own jail.

It currently costs $9.1 million a year to operate the Canyon County Jail. That comes to $24,931.50 per day, 365 days a year. $40/day for jail beds is a bargain no matter how you look at it. The bond repayment costs of $10k/day will fund the county buying 250 additional beds per day. Until we reach that point contract beds make sense. Especially when you read in the paper they are leaving 58 beds empty out of the 296 available. Jails are big expensive facilities that will bleed taxpayers dry if not managed properly. You can't ignore maintenance and cleanliness and not expect to get a lawsuit from the ACLU.

We present this for people to consider as we move into the next phase of trying to sell the voting public a new jail. The costs of $84/day per bed are for real and are a costly reminder of how much justice can we afford. THE GUARDIAN has also taken note we now have five times more people in this country than we did 30 years ago. The reason is President Nixon's WAR ON DRUGS. We have far too many non-violent people in jails and prisons and are bumping up against what taxpayers are willing to shell out for incarceration costs. There is a disconnect between the taxpayers, sheirff, prosecutor and the judges. Jail is not always the best option and it is time Canyon County got serious about other options to jail for low level offenders.

We now have 13 states that have decriminalized marijuana sales and possession. They have instituted medical marijuana laws. Oregon has proposal to legalize drugs will be out next week for legislative debate. California wants to tax cannabis at the rate of $50/oz and the proponents say it will raise $1.3 billion to the State Treasury. The President has instructed the Feds to leave medical marijuana sales locations alone if they are in compliance with their respective state laws. Point is, the WAR ON DRUGS is a complete failure. The political will to keep people locked up for drug use is getting called into question all over the country as the recession deepens and money for running prisons and jails dries up.

Mandatory sentencing is also getting called out for review by the Federal Government. California and their Three Strikes Laws are under scrutiny. The Economist magazine this week has an extensive article on the subject of people getting little to no punishment for the use of drugs in Europe. It is handled for the most part with fines and citations that go to support drug rehab and deterrence programs. On the average 0.2% of people charged with drug violations end up in prisons or jails and the sentences run from a few days to a average maximum of 20 months. Contrast that with the State of Texas where they have people in prison for 99years on marijuana charges.

It may be time to rethink the drug problems in Idaho. Billions of taxpayer dollars wasted on the Drug War since the Nixon years. Sentencing laws aimed at drug kingpins are routinely used against low level offenders and have filled prisons and jails.

One last comment on jails. They are also used as repositories for mentally ill people. In the 1980's President Reagan emptied out the mental hospitals and "mainstreamed" mentally ill people. The reality is these people had no safety net and ended up in jails and prisons. It is far cheaper to keep them in mental custodial care than in jails and prisons. We have got to figure out a better way to deal with this segment of society.

Final note, the Commishes get to fork over $190,000 of our tax dollars to the ACLU for their mismanagement of the Canyon County Jail. This is the final negotiated legal costs of ignoring their responsibility to provide a humane, clean, safe environment for inmates. Think of it as a $520/day surcharge on jail operations for the next year. The price paid for the lesson learned in jail costs and management by the Commishes.


  1. This is the most concise, factual entry I have seen on a Idaho blog site in ages.
    Prisons are money makers. The War on Drugs was simply a way to channel money to private prisons and Prison Boards and Districts.
    Great article!

  2. Why did the cost suddenly double to $84 overnight?

    Is that the overall average cost or just this fiscal years average? If it's this fiscal years average I would say that is misleading us taxpayers.

    Why would Kathy want to scare us with such a big number like that? Did she think we would buy her a bigger jail? I thought she was going to clean house at the county. Talk about a let down. She is in cahoots with the others for sure.

  3. Paul, I noticed the Caldwell School District is doing something with the Old Van Buren School. Do you know what they are up to?

  4. Because Kathy isn't trying to scare you, Paul is.

  5. Either Paul can't add, subtract, multiply, and divide or he got some bad info. It doesn't cost $84.00 a day.It's actually about the same as other counties coming in around $40.00 per day.

    Just what did Kathy Alder quote to you? Are you misinterpreting what she said? Did she quote $24,931.50 a day to you? Check your math Paul, it's faulty.

  6. Here is how you figure the cost/day for a jail bed (for those who don't already know). You take the labor budget for the year known as the "A" budget and add it to the maintenance budget, known at the "B" budget and it comes to $9,075,360 for the year. Divide that by the number of beds (296) equals $30,660 per bed per year. Divide $30,660 by 365 days in a year and it equals $84.00 per day per bed.

    The above does not cover the depreciation of the Jail building nor the original cost of the building, the bonding costs and the interest on the bonds. If you take the $6 million the jail cost when it opened in 1993 and straight line the depreciation for 20 years you can add another $2.77 or more per day to the cost before interest and underwriting on the bond.

    So it might really be closer $90/day per bed with all the hidden costs figured into the equation.

    This is how Commissioner Alder arrived at the cost per jail bed per day for those of you interested in the true costs of jail ops.

  7. "Paedophile admits sex with 18 month old baby but escapes jail."
    No wonder Britons are leaving in record numbers, is it too late to reverse the trend if we have an incompetent government which ignores the wishes of its electorate.Not a single shot has been fired (except by yobs),yet the country is run by a foreign power.Mr Straw as Foreign secretary said in 2004 "...a referendum on the EU would take place in 2006 if the Labour party win a third term in office."

  8. Is the total typical expense or perhaps this particular financial many years common? Whether it's this kind of financial decades common I might point out that's deceptive all of us citizens.

    The reason why might Kathy wish to discourage all of us along with this type of large amount that way? Would your woman feel we'd purchase the girl a more impressive prison? I figured your woman would house clean in the state. Speak about the dissatisfied. She's inside cahoots using the other people for certain.

  9. Great post full of useful tips! My site is fairly new and I am also having a hard time getting my readers to leave comments. Analytics shows they are coming to the site but I have a feeling “nobody wants to be first”.
    black friday

  10. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me to start my own BlogEngine blog now. Really the blogging is spreading its wings rapidly. Your write up is a fine example of it.
    mattress buying guide

  11. Hey – great blog, just looking around some blogs, seems a really nice platform you are using. I’m currently using WordPress for a few of my blogs but looking to change one of them over to a platform similar to yours as a trial run. Anything in particular you would recommend about it?
    memory foam mattress


A public discourse on the issues of the day makes the world a better place.

We welcome comments but they will be moderated and edited if too long or do not have anything to do with the post.
Agree or disagree just do it without profanity or it won't get posted. Try to keep your comments to no more than 300 words. Too long and I will try to edit it down or simply delete the comment. The whole idea is to get people to read your comment. Don't use 10 words when one will do the job.

It's OK to have a difference of opinion but keep it civil. I have used the "delete" feature on myself at times.

The ANONYMOUS feature for comments seems to be the most user friendly. People have commented they have difficulty with the other methods of posting comments.